Gordon's Gardens

Exploring California's tended and untended landscapes


13 Comments

Tree Art or Tree Torture?

I have recently joined the Pinterest bandwagon and enjoy pinning and re-pinning interesting garden ideas on my board “Plantspiration.”  That’s “plant” + “inspiration,” not “plant” + “perspiration,” although based on some of the great garden ideas I’ve come across, the latter is probably also true.

When I’m avoiding doing something I don’t want to do, I often enjoy exploring the gardening section from the Pinterest iPhone app that crashes all the time.  Recently I came across a picture that really upset me.  It was a picture of a tree pruned to be a chair.  It’s called “pooktre,” but my immediate reaction was to call it “tree torture.”  An artform, yes, but I have a hard time with it.

Image from pooktre website (http://pooktre.com)

Rather than immediately starting TPAP (Trees and People Against Pooktre), I stopped to think if I was overreacting.  I had to ask myself, “Is there any difference between pooktre and bonsai or a Ficus benjamina with braided trunks or an espalier?”  In terms of the basic idea – specific pruning (and, in this case, also grafting) to produce a desired effect – the answer is no.  But I feel very differently when looking at a beautiful bonsai specimen or enjoying the sight of that braided ficus while anxiously sitting in the doctor’s waiting room than I do when looking at pictures of kids hanging in trees that were grown to look like stick figures of people with crazy hands and hair.

Am I being too much of a tree purist to appreciate this very time-consuming pruning and grafting process?  Am I being narrow minded, or just logical?  Part of me feels guilty for putting down the hard work of the people behind pooktre, but most of me feels disturbed and sad for the trees.  To each their own, right?

Now I ask you, what do you think about pooktre.  Is it tree art or tree torture?  I look forward to hearing what you have to say.

* * * * * * * * * * * *

Update 4/13/2012:

In just a few days I received many, many great responses on here and on various LinkedIn groups!  Wow!  Thanks everyone for your perspectives and insights.

So my conclusion: After all the feedback, I do believe my gut reaction was just as I originally thought…a bit extreme.  Is pooktre different than other forms of topiary or pruning?  My answer is still no.  Is the tree healthy?  According to most people who responded, the answer is a resounding yes (right species for this kind of manipulation, lush canopy, appropriate mulch, constant attention, etc.).  So while pooktre is distasteful to me, it’s no different than not liking any other type of pruning technique that does not harm the tree.  It’s not to be confused with topping  (which is a fineable offense in my town, and a pretty expensive one at that).

Now, as an art form, do I like it?  Definitely not.  But is it an artform?  Of course.  So is Marcel Duchamp’s “Fountain,” although others may say it’s just a urinal.  Not everyone enjoys or appreciates the same kind of art.  If you like pooktre and you didn’t know it existed until reading this post, then I’m glad I was able to introduce you to it.

While people had some great responses, the one that struck me the most was by Alan Bryant, owner of Alan Bryant Gardening Services in the UK, on the Proper Pruners LinkedIn group: “[A] question you need to ask yourself is: does it encourage the owner to use their garden more.  For some, gardening becomes merely an exercise in religiously maintaining the previous owners garden. Likelihood is that such owners are disinterested in a garden they rarely use. What a waste. I always encourage owners to ‘own’ their gardens, by truly making them theirs.”

There it is…the “Aha!” moment.  This really made me think about pooktre from a different perspective and allowed me to appreciate it for what it is.  Those kids in that picture above are having a great time hanging in the tree.  Not many children can say they have a tree in the shape of a person in their yard!  I know from my own childhood (see my Family Bonds post) that experiences like this can lead to a life-long love of nature and gardening.  I hope it does for those children.


Leave a comment

Agapanthus orientalis, more commonly known as Lily of the Nile or Gas Station Lily

Agapanthus

Agapanthus orientalis inflorescence

Some people might be shocked, and perhaps will even write me off, because I am devoting my first plant post to Lily of the Nile (Agapanthus orientalis), AKA agapanthus. This plant is commonly used in designed California landscapes because of it’s beauty and how easy it is to grow in our climate. It is often found in pots at gas stations, planted in small islands amongst rows of cars in strip mall parking lots, and at one point was often seen along California highway onramps when the state had money to invest in “freeway beautification.” Of course, when there becomes an influx of too many of one thing, that thing begins to lose value and favor in the eyes of some. Perhaps this “upturning of the nose” is more common in California because we’re fortunate enough to have agapanthuses blooming year round. Maybe if we lived on the East Coast some of us would appreciate them a bit more and not give them common names like “gas station lily,” “freeway lily,” or “obnoxioupanthus.”

Gas Station Lily

Agapanthus orientalis inflorescence and leaves

But I am not here to further promote the anti-agapanthus movement. While it isn’t my favorite plant on earth, it does stir up childhood memories for me of my Grandparents’ backyard in Los Angeles. As someone attuned to plants, a lot of my memories are strongly tied to the sights and smells of the flora I encounter (just wait until I write my posts on Artemisia tridentata, Pinus jeffreyi, and Ephedra californica!) When I think of childhood Easter egg hunts in Grandma and Grandpa’s backyard, I think of how my aunt used to purposely hide hard-boiled eggs amongst the snails living around the base of the agapanthus plant next to the giant grapefruit tree. I was one of the few grandkids who wasn’t disgusted by the sight of a slimy snail creeping along a poorly-died egg in the dirt. I wasn’t going to eat the shell anyway…..I let my brother do that instead.

white agapanthus

Agapanthus orientalis with white flowers, found growing in the St. Mary's Park neighborhood of San Francisco

If personal memories of mine or of your own aren’t enough to inspire appreciation of Agapanthus orientalis, perhaps it’s name will be of interest. Botanical names are all latinized and typically get their monikers in one of these ways: 1) after the person who first recorded the plants existence, 2) after specific characteristics of the plant, or 3) after the location where the plant was discovered. So “orientalis” should make you think “Orient,” and therefore coming from somewhere in Asia or nearby. But Agapanthus orientalis is from South Africa. How can this be? Is the Orient really just anywhere that’s not Europe? Well, it was for the explorers back in the day when various European monarchs were sending them off to find places to conquer and colonize. There wasn’t much a difference to the first people who brought Agapanthus orientalis to Europe whether they picked the plant up in Africa, Indonesia, or what is now known as Florida. It was all the Orient to them. So we who talk poorly about this plant nowadays weren’t the first to disrespect it. How many other ways can we offend this plant? Eh, it doesn’t really matter. Look at how well they grow. It’s obvious they don’t care what we say about them or call them.

Plants like agapanthus serve many purposes: 1) They are relatively easy to grow, so even the garden novice can enjoy some horticultural success and be inspired to have faith in their green thumbs. 2) When grown in groups and not completely neglected, they grow large and make us feel like we are in a lush and perhaps even tropical environment. 3) Those spikes of large violet or dark blue or white inflorescences contrasting against the giant mounds of long, bright green leaves truly do inspire you to wish you were somewhere calm and peaceful – or maybe just confuse your mind into thinking you’re not really about to sit in what could be hours of traffic on the freeway.

So next time you see Agapanthus orientalis growing in that gas station planter or next to where you parked your car, think about their beauty, the memories they may inspire in you, or feel bad for how we humans have mistreated them over the centuries. This will take your mind off the fact that gas is almost $4.00 a gallon and the last thing you want to do after working all day is go grocery shopping.

Peter Pan

Agapanthus orientalis

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.